MLS Cup Playoffs: First Round Preview

MLS Cup Playoffs: First Round Preview

MLS Matchday 3 Preview and Free Picks

Last Updated on November 20, 2026 6:56 pm by Erwin Noguera

Both ninth seeds won. Both eighth seeds went out at home. FC Cincinnati won 3-1 at Orlando City. Real Salt Lake drew 1-1 at Seattle and won the shootout 4-2 in front of 29,628 at Lumen Field. The MLS Wild Card round was supposed to reward the higher seed with a home tie, and it did not reward either of them.

So the bracket is complete, and it contains a club with a negative goal difference. Cincinnati finished the regular season at minus eight (the worst of the sixteen teams still playing), and their reward is Nashville, who are plus forty-six.

Fifty-four goals of margin separate the two clubs in the Sunday afternoon fixture.

Round One is a best-of-three and Game 1 of all eight series runs from Saturday to Tuesday. Eight days ago we previewed this round with two participants unknown and four ties unpriced. Both of those gaps are now closed, and one of the things we told you has turned out to be wrong.

A new era of peer-to-peer sports betting has arrived from TSMx. Trade sports peer-to-peer for better odds, and claim 1,000 TSMx Coins + $5 in TSMx Credit when you sign up now with our special link.

The Wild Card Round Settled Two Things

FixtureResultAdvanced
Orlando City (8) v FC Cincinnati (9)1-3Cincinnati
Seattle Sounders (8) v Real Salt Lake (9)1-1, 4-2 on penaltiesReal Salt Lake

We flagged on November 12 that both Wild Card hosts were the worse club by goal difference: Cincinnati were minus eight against Orlando’s minus fifteen, and Real Salt Lake plus one against Seattle’s minus two. Both of the better-margin sides won.

The format note also held exactly as written: no extra time, penalties immediately. Seattle and Real Salt Lake went straight from ninety minutes to the spot.

The Complete Game 1 Board

Series (Game 1)DayETHomeDrawAwayTotalHold
New England (3) v Philadelphia (6)Sat, Nov 212:00 PM31.2%25.9%42.8%3.58.58%
FC Dallas (2) v Portland (7)Sat, Nov 214:00 PM49.6%23.5%26.9%3.57.79%
Inter Miami (2) v Columbus (7)Sat, Nov 216:00 PM59.7%20.2%20.2%3.57.76%
Nashville (1) v Cincinnati (9)Sun, Nov 224:00 PM63.1%20.1%16.8%3.58.17%
Chicago (4) v Charlotte (5)Sun, Nov 226:30 PM57.8%21.6%20.6%3.57.74%
Vancouver (1) v Real Salt Lake (9)Sun, Nov 228:30 PM62.7%19.7%17.6%3.58.07%
St. Louis (3) v LAFC (6)Mon, Nov 238:00 PM39.9%26.2%34.0%2.59.09%
San Jose (4) v Houston (5)Tue, Nov 2410:00 PM43.6%26.9%29.5%2.59.29%

Games one and three are at the higher seed. Game 2 is at the lower seed on November 27 and 28, and Game 3, if needed, is on December 2.

Six of the eight totals are 3.5. The only two at 2.5 are the two series the market cannot separate: St. Louis against LAFC and San Jose against Houston. That is the market saying the close games will also be the tight ones.

Nashville Against the Worst Goal Difference Left

Nashville finished on seventy-seven points with a plus-forty-six goal difference and twenty-five goals conceded in thirty-four matches: 0.74 a game.

Cincinnati finished on forty-six points at minus eight, having conceded seventy-five. They are the only club in the remaining sixteen with a negative margin.

And they just won 3-1 on the road in a single-elimination match, which is the argument for them and the only one.

The market has Nashville at 63.1%, which is the second-shortest home price of the round. A 0.74 defensive record against a side that conceded 2.21 a game is the most lopsided pairing in the bracket by any measure you choose.

Vancouver against Real Salt Lake is the same shape one notch down. Plus forty against plus one, 62.7% against 17.6%, and Real Salt Lake arriving on the back of a penalty shootout, the one route into this round that tells you least about a team.

Philadelphia Are the Only Road Favourite

Of the eight Game 1 fixtures, exactly one has the away side favoured.

Philadelphia are 42.8% at New England, who are 31.2% at home. This is the position we took on November 12, and the only thing that has changed is that the price got slightly longer: they were +105 then and are +115 now.

The case has not moved either. Philadelphia’s goal difference is plus fourteen. New England’s is plus eight. New England won eighteen matches to Philadelphia’s fourteen, and drew four to Philadelphia’s eight: a profile that wins and loses rather than one that controls games.

The 3.5 total is the detail worth noting. The market expects goals in a game between the sixth seed and the third, which is not how a cagey first leg usually gets priced.

We said eight days ago that we would take this on the series rather than on game one, and we are holding that. A best-of-three with games one and three at New England means Philadelphia have to win on the road at least once, and Saturday is the cheapest chance they will get.

LAFC Are Still Underpriced, and Now There Is a Price to Point At

On November 12 we called LAFC the most mispriced club in the field and could not show you a number, because the St. Louis tie had no odds published.

Now it does, and the argument survives.

LAFC’s goal difference is plus twelve. St. Louis’s is plus eleven. LAFC are the sixth seed and St. Louis the third, and LAFC are 34.0% to St. Louis’s 39.9%.

The reason LAFC are seeded sixth is eleven draws. Twelve wins, eleven draws, eleven losses is a record the points table punishes, and the margin does not, and in a knockout round, draws stop costing you anything.

This is also the highest price of the round at 9.09% hold, which cuts the other way: the number we like is in the market we would least want to pay for.

San Jose against Houston is the other genuinely close one: 43.6% against 29.5% with the highest draw price of the round at 26.9%. Houston scored forty-three goals in thirty-four matches, the fewest of the sixteen clubs still alive, and they are the fifth seed because they conceded exactly as many.

⚠ The Market Got Cheaper, and Our Advice Has to Change

Eight days ago we wrote that MLS playoff three-way prices were “roughly twice as expensive as the NFL and meaningfully worse than European football,” that the board held between 8.8% and 11.2%, and that we would “avoid the three-way match markets entirely at these prices.”

The board now holds between 7.74% and 9.29%, averaging 8.31%.

Every number came down. The expensive end fell by nearly two points.

We were right that 11.2% is not a market you beat with an opinion. We were wrong to treat it as a permanent feature of the competition. What we were actually looking at was four unpriced ties and a board the books had not finished sharpening, and when the field was resolved, the prices tightened.

8.31% is still expensive. It is twice the NFL’s 4.2%, and well above the Premier League board we priced this morning at 4.76%. But “avoid entirely” was the wrong instruction, and the correct one is narrower: at 8.31% you need a real edge, and we think there is one in exactly one series.

What We Would Do

LAFC at St. Louis is the position, and we are taking it on the series rather than on Monday’s game. A club with the better goal difference, seeded three places lower because it drew eleven matches, in a format where draws are worthless. The 9.09% hold on the single game is the reason to express it across the tie rather than on the night.

Philadelphia at New England we are holding from November 12, with the same caveat: it is on the series, and the market already agrees, which usually means the edge is thin.

We would not touch Nashville at 63.1% or Vancouver at 62.7%. Both are correct prices on the two best teams in the competition against the two clubs that came through a one-off match. There is nothing to win there.

And the series we would simply watch is San Jose against Houston. 43.6%, 26.9%, 29.5%, a 2.5 total, and two clubs separated by one point and six goals of margin over thirty-four matches. That is a market with no opinion, and this time we are not going to pretend we have one either.

One number to carry into next week: not one semifinalist can be known before December 2. Game 3 of any series that goes the distance is that Wednesday, and everything above is the first third of eight separate stories.

At Gambyl Casino, the action goes beyond the field. Explore all MLS news, predictions, and betting odds while enjoying a complete Online Casino experience, with fast action and intuitive gameplay.

Written by

Related Articles & More Free Betting Picks